Detroit to Dover - Experiences of an open water swimmer
  • Home
  • Blog
  • English Channel
  • Bio
  • Gallery
  • Support
  • Links

A TAIL of Two Swimmers--Charity Island Lighthouse Swim, July 10, 2011

7/10/2011

14 Comments

 
I had never been to Charity Island in Lake Huron until yesterday--when I swam there. On a clear day, we can see the island beyond the US Gypsum crib in Lake Huron south of Tawas City. In fact, as you head north towards Tawas on US-23, you can get a closer view from Au Gres. I had heard tales of people swimming there from Au Gres many years ago, making that a five or six mile swim. So last year, we figured a swim to Charity Island from Tawas City would be roughly 15 miles. This summer they added a boat cruise from East Tawas to Charity Island. For $79, you can experience a terrific boat cruise to Charity Island with snacks and drinks, fish or steak dinner on the island, dessert on your way home during sunset, plus learn a bit about the Island. I started to think that if I just swam to Charity Island it would be a great training swim as my English Channel swim nears. Though not as delectible as steak and fish, I could have a few liquid meals in the Lake, maybe feed a few fish and get a swimmers' eye view of the lighthouse and island--and not to mention, have tales to tell. Where do the tails come in? Keep reading.

We arrived in Tawas late Friday night and I was leaning towards a Sunday swim, so we could have Saturday to make last minute preparations. Looking at the marine forecast, Saturday was definitely a better swimming day if you like calmer water. With winds only 2-6 mph forecast for early Saturday morning, it meant little waves. Sunday morning called for a swim into the SE winds 8-12 mph. After some discussion, we agreed that Sunday's conditions would better prepare me for the unknown and give us more time to pack our bags and relax a bit. Saturday was mostly spent prepping for the swim. I mixed my energy drink in four water bottles, we contacted the Coast Guard (since I was going to be swimming into a shipping lane), warmed and mixed Vaseline with pure lanonlin to prevent chafing, went for a short swim and a two mi dog walk, found time for reading and some jetskiing before going to bed at 8 p.m. I had no trouble falling asleep.

However, it was the reading earlier in the day that presented the biggest threat in my mind for Sunday. I'm currently reading, Wind, Waves, and Sunburn (A Brief History of Marathon Swimming), by Conrad Wennerberg, loaned to me by a fellow Michigan Masters swimmer. That was when I read about Marilyn Bell's 1954 Lake Ontario crossing. It was in her first hour of swimming that she discarded her goggles and shortly after when the first lamprey eel attached itself to her bathing suit. Since she was used to this in her training swims, she simply pinched under its' suckers and plucked the parasite from her suit, like her swim mate, Cliff Lumsden, had taught her. He too, was badgered by the pests on training swims, and once he crushed ones head between his teeth and threw it.

I shouldn't have done it, but I did it anyways. I ran to the computer to Google "lamprey eel-Lake Huron." I remembered reading about how they were problematic in most of the Great Lakes and wondered if they were attracted to light sticks, clipped to a swimmers' suit, say at four in the morning. Just happens I found a study that showed eels were indeed attracted to light. After my Google research session, complete with illustrations of lamprey eels attached to trout, I knew two things were certain. 1- I was bound to have an eery eel encounter and 2- There was absolutely no way I would put an eel in my mouth and bite its head off.

The crew and I awoke at 3 a.m. to the sound of the waves crashing on the sea wall. Each of us were busy scurrying around the house, grabbing some food and loading the car for the marina. Noah, Karen and myself took a less-drowsy Dramamine and by 4 a.m, the crew headed to the Marina, leaving Karen and I at the house. Karen rolled on her wetsuit while I ate a banana and a regular oatmeal packet, along w/ a bottle of energy drink. Next, we attached our lightsticks (see previous blog) with safety pins to the back of our suits (hers on her wetsuit string), and clipped the LED blinking lights to our goggle straps. This was when I ran around saying, "It's great to have a tail--this swim is now called 'A Tail of Two Swimmers." Giddy and ready to swim--yet, hoping I didn't resemble a trout. We stepped into the darknes on the back patio,  where we set up the bucket of lanolin-vaseline concoction on some old towels on the lawn. Wearing disposable gloves, all the while our lightsticks were attracting bugs, Karen applied some of the sticky mess to underneath my bathing suit straps and places I was known to chafe in previous swims [learning experiences]. We continued to look out into Lake Huron for the green and white running lights of our escort boat, coming from the Tawas Bay Marina. In the meantime, in anxious nervousness, I must have put my hands on the lanolin six or seven times and ran back into the house to wash.

Karen and I navigated down the sea wall steps cautiously, as the waves smashed against our shins. I looked back at the house and noticed that we left the downstairs well illuminated for the boat to spot us. We waded out to the end of the dock, where the sand ended and rocks congregated. I thought the water would have been cooler than it was. It felt terrific. We saw the green and white lights bobbing in the deeper water waiting for us, so we started swimming out towards the escort boat. I was hoping I didn't swim into 'anything that went bump in the night,' aka Mr. Lamprey Eel.

I had trouble maintaining sight of the bow's red running light if I fell just behind it, so I did tell my crew and we moved a lightstick closer to it. With Karen on my left shoulder, and the boat on my right, I tried to swim parallel to the boat. A few times I heard, "left" and "too close," even with ear plugs. Turns out, the only thing I bumped into in that first half hour was Karen, my companion swimmer. I think we both screamed and apologized. Good thing I didn't have to bite her head off. This was a good practice of sensory deprivation, which initally was the root of some anxiety. I was able to tell who was who on the boat, because of their different colored life jackets and lightsticks. I kept a watchful eye on the boat's lights and the attached lightsticks when I breathed towards them. Every time I breathed to my left to spot Karen's lights, I hoped I wasn't swimming into the boat. I'm thankful I had a companion for my first night swim. Somewhere in the darkness I was able to see the "1 mi" sign that I had printed. Karen placed all of the signs (numbers, sayings, etc.) in clear, protective sheets, and sealed them with clear packaging tape. Laminating them was way too expensive and we're trying to save as much money as we can for the Channel trip. We learned that they also need to be sturdier, so we'll add a piece of cardboard to each one. They are portable and easy to pack, once placed in a 3-ring binder. The first feeding came around mile 1 to practice in the dark. Noah tossed in the TYR water bottle attached to kite string and I couldn't locate it. "Turn the spotlight on the bottle," someone said from the boat. Learning experience.

When we approached the US Gypsum crib in the dark, all I could really see was the bright red light on top. I couldn't see any of the wires or interesting objects on the bottom. The first time I ever swam to the US Gypsum crib in Tawas Bay, I was so proud. I climbed aboard the jet ski, my husband handed me a lifejacket to put on and then a seagull pooped on my face to welcome us. I have photos. This time I think we snuck past the sleeping seagulls. Karen stayed in the water for the first 90 minutes and then Noah hopped in, wearing his wetsuit. Once we got past the crib, I noticed the waves picked up and the boat was getting tossed like a salad. I even said to the crew, "if it's too wavy, we can turn around and swim to the other lighthouse and back." Lynn replied, "It's okay. Keep swimming." I could just start to see the faint reddish glow to the sky, which brought comfort. Noah swam a half hour and then he disappeared into the boat. He later said he was feeding the fish the entire half hour but wanted to serve his time in the water with me. I love him. And for the record, no lamprey eel sightings or touchings at that point.

The next few hours were a constant battle with four foot waves. I saw my husband wearing a blue hoodie with his head hung over the far side of the boat and knew he was seasick. I was later told it had rained three times on the crew and it was quite cloudy. Every feed I drank my energy mix and every other feed it seemed I was offered small amounts of something different. With every new mile card, I saw Lynn move to the stern. Classical conditioning was in effect and naturally my behavioral response was "Food is coming!"  Every other feed she would reach out a metal basket on a long pole, holding a small green plastic cup, also attached to kite string. Twice I discovered diced peaches in heavy syrup, twice I was given a Peter Rabbit Organic fruit snack, a few Jellybelly SportBeans, once a few tiny Powerbar protein balls, once a tiny bite of Milky Way candy bar (turned that down), and once a hard boiled egg (turned that down faster than the candy). Breakfast and lunch in Lake Huron. I was asked to drink a half a water bottle at every feed and did note that while fighting the waves, fish are fed after every feed.

I remained in good spirits the entire swim, which is credit to my wonderful crew and family and the energy drink. I swam many hours by myself and just kept my head down. When someone on board said, "We can see Charity!" and asked "Can you see it?" I did a few forward sightings and responded, "I ONLY see a lot of water." I didn't waste any more time trying to spot it because all I could see were giant waves heading my way. I was too worried about how to learn to pee while swimming instead of wasting time during a feed. Several feeds I told jokes or commented that they should call ahead to Charity Island and make a swim-ahead reservation for table #5. When Lynn showed me the sign that said, "Great day for a swim," I saw nothing but cloudy skies and lifted my head and joked back, "Great day for a nap." Towards the end, I also told the crew to change that dinner reservation to a bed & breakfast. I also kept thinking about getting a carmel apple at the Village Chocolatier.

Finally at mile 13, I could see the Charity Island Lighthouse and a bunch of fishing vessels. Karen re-entered the water with me at mile 12 for a half hour and again when we had about a half mile to go. The clouds were starting to break-up and the rocky bottom was becoming more visable. One of the Coast Guard guys in Tawas told us that Charity Island was very rocky so I pictured big boulders. Once it was too shallow, the boat stayed in the deeper water while Karen and I swam as far as we could, which was about 75 yards from the shore. We had to do some shallow breaststroke pulls to glide over the rocks that our freestyle fingers were touching. Each of us hand selected a few rocks. I stuffed one in my suit and Karen jammed a few in her wetsuit to swim back to the boat. Finally I kneeled, then stood up slowly and we raised our hands in celebration of the successful swim. We swam back to the boat, showed them our rocks and exchanged hugs. I drank two bottles of water and had a piece of turkey after putting on a wool hat, neck gaiter, fleece shirt and pants for the swift boat ride back to the Tawas Bay Marina. Thank you, Lynn, Mark, Noah, and Karen and the people in the Tawas area for your support and kind words. I did later get that carmel apple. But I was too tired to eat it. This Saturday I think I'll take that dinner boat cruise to celebrate my birthday and enjoy the ride. Thank you for reading and please leave a comment. :)

p.s. Many people have said, "WHY?" I will leave you with this quote... "The more you do, the more you discover you can do, and the more you want to do." On this day, I swam 16 miles to Charity Island. Marathon swimming is a battle, the biggest test of human spirit I've come across in athletics. Every small victory yields further challenges.
14 Comments
tracy durham
7/11/2011 12:48:36 pm

As soon as I read the third paragraph, I thought 'what the fuzz is a lamprey eel???' I looked it up on Wikipedia. Good gracious! Those things are nasty beyond nastiness! Then I read your similar reaction in the fourth paragraph. :)
Oh, and I think you slipped in to pirate-talk again. "I did tell me crew to move the light stick closer or else walk the plank, aargh"

Reply
cheryl rivard
7/11/2011 06:04:14 pm

Congrats on the Charity Island Lighthouse Swim! Loved reading about it, and the pics are great! Keep that swimming spirit going as you progress toward your ultimate goal:)

Reply
Carol Morrissey
7/11/2011 09:30:57 pm

Keep up the good work Jenny. Looks like you are just about ready.

Reply
Julie Martensen
7/12/2011 12:23:25 am

Great story and photos! I am proud of you. I guess the eels couldn't keep up with you.

Reply
Sheryl Walsh
7/12/2011 05:39:26 am

Your writing made me feel like I was there with you. I could see your water smile. You need to publish your stories. They are written so well.

Reply
dave potter
7/12/2011 11:44:59 am

Keep up the great work, love reading you posts, you are truley inspiring !!!!

Reply
Lana
7/12/2011 11:46:07 am

Amazing and inspiring as always. Proud of you and your fish feeding husband.

Reply
Toni Le Master
7/12/2011 08:01:27 pm

Congrats on the night swim! Our thoughts and prayers are with you.

Reply
Mia
7/12/2011 10:51:08 pm

Way to go JD! Reading your "tail" made me smile. I'm so glad the eels stayed away.

Reply
Jennifer Parks link
7/13/2011 12:40:15 am

Great "tail," Jenny! It's great that Karen can swim with you. By the way, I pee a little at a time...spreading it out so I don't feel uncomfortable! Kind of glad you got some waves so you're not daunted by them. Shoulders?? How are they? So glad you're enjoying the whole journey toward the Channel; think that these swims are really important part of your whole story! Keep it up, JD! You'll be leaving the day we have our Big Red Lighthouse OW at Holland...we'll be thinking of you! L, JP

Reply
Richard C.
7/17/2011 11:28:11 pm

That is an AWESOME swim. It's one thing to think about undertaking a swim like this one (and the anxiety and joy that go with it), and it's another to actually do it. YOU DID IT.

Richard C. (An aging age group triathlete that enjoys living vicariously through your exploits)

Reply
Jerry link
10/5/2012 11:54:12 pm

Congrats on the Charity Island Lighthouse Swim!

Reply
Devin Benner
7/14/2020 01:46:21 pm

Hi Jenny, The tales are true. I swam from just south of Whitestone point in AuGres to the middle of the east side of Big Charity (7.6 miles) in 2001. I claim to be the first until someone tells me different. 4:40 was the time from beach to beach. I was 35 yrs old. Congratulations on your swim. Great time. That is super fast!!!

Reply
Devin Benner
7/15/2020 07:59:40 am

Correction: I swam to the middle of the WEST side of Big Charity

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

     

    Picture
    JD Birmelin

    Archives

    April 2012
    February 2012
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.